Tuesday, June 18 2013, 09:14 AM MDT
Deaf Woman Wants To Be E.M.T; Claims Discrimination
By Matt Gephardt and Michelle Poe
(KUTV) Ashley Kuster says that she wants to save lives by becoming an emergency medical technician. To do so, she took the right classes at Weber State University and she passed all the exams. Now all she has to do is take the state test to become certified but she is not being given that chance because she is deaf.
Deaf or not, Ashley says she can do the job and wants the chance to prove it. But she cannot take the state test without a written recommendation from Weber State and Weber State says they will not write that recommendation because she cannot hear without hearing aids.
“I want to be able to take my test, pass the test, either fail or pass on my own account, not on somebody else’s account of my supposed failure,” Ashley says.
Ashley says she called the state asking for help but got none.
“They stated to me that I need to take it up with my coordinator. There's nothing they can do until I take it up with my coordinator.”
And when the Weber State coordinator would not budge, Ashley decided to Get Gephardt.
2News looked up the Utah state rules to be an E.M.T. and they do specifically talk about hearing being a necessity. However, the rules also state that "reasonable accommodations are considered by the bureau on a case by case basis." Ashley says, in her case that would be hearing aids.
2News took those rules back to Weber State University and the director of media relations, John Kowalewski. In lieu of a re-reading of the state standards, this time Weber State relented and decided to write Ashley a letter of recommendation to take the state E.M.T. test. Kowalewski blames confusion on the part of Ashley’s instructor for why the letter was not originally written.
“Going forward we have greater clarification on how our E.M.T educators are expected to follow up with the state,” Kowalewski says. And he adds, “Great effort was put in to assure that Ashley was not disadvantaged in any way.”
With that, Ashley was finally allowed to take the state exam, and she passed. Ashley says she plans to further her education before attempting to get a job as an E.M.T. Job or not, Ashley is the first hearing impaired person to be certified as an E.M.T. in the state of Utah. We found that there are at least 25 other deaf persons who work as E.M.T’s, paramedics and firefighters in the United States.
(Copyright 2012 Sinclair Broadcasting Group)
(KUTV) Ashley Kuster says that she wants to save lives by becoming an emergency medical technician. To do so, she took the right classes at Weber State University and she passed all the exams. Now all she has to do is take the state test to become certified but she is not being given that chance because she is deaf.
Deaf or not, Ashley says she can do the job and wants the chance to prove it. But she cannot take the state test without a written recommendation from Weber State and Weber State says they will not write that recommendation because she cannot hear without hearing aids.
“I want to be able to take my test, pass the test, either fail or pass on my own account, not on somebody else’s account of my supposed failure,” Ashley says.
Ashley says she called the state asking for help but got none.
“They stated to me that I need to take it up with my coordinator. There's nothing they can do until I take it up with my coordinator.”
And when the Weber State coordinator would not budge, Ashley decided to Get Gephardt.
2News looked up the Utah state rules to be an E.M.T. and they do specifically talk about hearing being a necessity. However, the rules also state that "reasonable accommodations are considered by the bureau on a case by case basis." Ashley says, in her case that would be hearing aids.
2News took those rules back to Weber State University and the director of media relations, John Kowalewski. In lieu of a re-reading of the state standards, this time Weber State relented and decided to write Ashley a letter of recommendation to take the state E.M.T. test. Kowalewski blames confusion on the part of Ashley’s instructor for why the letter was not originally written.
“Going forward we have greater clarification on how our E.M.T educators are expected to follow up with the state,” Kowalewski says. And he adds, “Great effort was put in to assure that Ashley was not disadvantaged in any way.”
With that, Ashley was finally allowed to take the state exam, and she passed. Ashley says she plans to further her education before attempting to get a job as an E.M.T. Job or not, Ashley is the first hearing impaired person to be certified as an E.M.T. in the state of Utah. We found that there are at least 25 other deaf persons who work as E.M.T’s, paramedics and firefighters in the United States.
(Copyright 2012 Sinclair Broadcasting Group)
News Photos & Videos - Submit Your Photos Here
![]() |
![]() |
More Gephardt Stories
Company Offering Utahns Airfare "Award" in Legal Mess
One Home Alarm; Two Bills
Lehi Company Hired to Restore Car Fails to Perform
Imposters Using Iconic Commercial to Dupe Seniors
Utah School Claims No Affiliation With School Advertiser
After Construction Delays, Lowes Silences Customer
Hundreds of Complaints Hound Car Selling Website
Company Goes Out Of Business Before Completing Portrait Order
Man Waits 4 Months For Recalled Part
Website Selling 'Free' State Paperwork
Good Question: Paid Holidays
An Unexpected Check In The Mail That's NOT A Scam
Police: New Utah Law, 'Revictimizes Victims' of Theft
Infomercial Product's Shipping, Handling Costs More Than The Product
Good Question: Is My Cell Phone Spying On Me?
Cell Phone Companies Have Secret 'Black List'
Unaware Cab Driver Used As Crook's Pawn
Swallow Complaint Delayed At Commerce Boss' Suggestion
Kidney Donation Can Be Free To The Donor
Recap of ShredFest 2013
Man Who Already Paid Ticket Now Facing Criminal Charges
Popular Pass-of-all-Passes Faces Shipment Delays
Holladay Woman Stumbles Upon Fake ID Website
Thieves Lure Prey with Promise of Free Dogs
Good Question: Why Are Investors So Jumpy?
Cell Phone Bills Crammed With Unwanted "Premium Services"
Computer Glitch Causes Red Butte Garden Concert Controversy
Georgia Company Vanishes After Ripping Off Utahns
Sentimental Letters, Photos Reunited With Family
Good Question: Freeway Sign Times
Prison Inmate Work-Program Competes With Private Business
Tracking a Package Leaves Consumer Vulnerable to I.D. Thieves
TV Manufacturer Delays Honoring Warranty
Company Owes Woman Money But Sends Her To Collections
Good Question: Why Do Coupons Have A Minuscule Cash Value?
Orem Man Wins Long Battle With Ins. Over Fault
Windshield Replacer: "I'm Not Trying to Screw Anyone"
Bank Of America Misapplies Funds
People Fighting for their Pictures after a Major Portrait Studies Goes Under
Online 'Steal' Turns Costly for Customer
Woman Whose Car is Totaled Waits Months for Payout
Relatively New Siding Falling off Home
Good Question: What Is 'The Cloud?'
Towed Car Owners Have New Rights
Elderly Utahns Lose $1 Million A Day
Get Gephardt: Three Day Right to Refund Not Honored
Good Question: Why do Fans Throw Hats When a Hockey Player Scores Thrice?
Police Searching for Accused Thief who Targeted Home Alarm Customers
Phone Company Refuses to Cancel Service
Windshield Installer Rips Off Customer
Sewer Company Relents, Helps Flooded Residents
Cars Held For Weeks at Local Repair Shop
Good Question: HOV Lanes in an Emergency
Huge Bills For Newborn After Insurance Co. Error
Get Gephardt: Gross and Expensive Cleanup for WVC Homeowners
After Months Of Fighting VA, Family's Claim Approved
Good Question: Who Is Behind Flyers In Utah Promising Airfare Award
TV Maker Refuses to Honor Warranty
Utility Company Ignores Pleas To Fix Downed Line
Reception Center Owner Charged with Fraud









